Why Cooling Matters: Inside the Thermal Design of Synchronous Machines

Introduction

Electric motors and synchronous machines work hard to keep our world turning, literally. From industrial drives to power generation, these machines convert electrical energy into motion with remarkable precision. But with great power comes great heat. Managing this heat effectively is crucial to maintaining performance, extending lifespan, and preventing costly failures. In this post, we’ll explore why cooling is so important and take a closer look at the mechanisms engineers use to keep synchronous machines running smoothly under pressure.

Different motor types have unique cooling needs:

Induction Motors require airflow over the stator and rotor to dissipate heat generated due to electrical and core losses.

Synchronous Motors require cooling for the rotor (which contains field windings or permanent magnets) and the stator.

DC Motors: Heat is generated in the armature (rotor) and field windings. Cooling systems must account for brush and commutator heat.

Stepper Motors: Generate heat in the stator due to high current. Cooling is often passive or involves forced airflow for high-performance designs.

Environmental and Operational Considerations

Ambient Temperature: High ambient temperatures may require enhanced cooling systems.

Dust and Moisture: Enclosures like Totally Enclosed Water-Cooled (TEWC) or Totally Enclosed Air-Cooled (TEAC) designs protect against environmental contaminants.

Load Duty Cycle: Continuous-duty motors need robust cooling, while intermittent-duty motors may rely on natural cooling.

Application Requirements: Motors in hazardous areas (e.g., mines or chemical plants) may need explosion-proof cooling designs.

Efficient cooling ensures: Prolonged motor life by preventing overheating. Maintained performance and efficiency. Reduced risk of insulation failure or mechanical wear.

Open Machines

In open machines, cooling is achieved by natural or forced airflow, with the air being drawn into the machine through openings in its housing and expelled into the surrounding environment. This design is commonly seen in machines like car alternators and small industrial motors.

Air is drawn directly into the motor housing. Fans, often mounted on the rotor, assist in circulating the air across the motor’s internal components, including the windings and stator. For example in car alternators the compact design and need for efficient, passive cooling make open machines ideal. Most suitable for small to medium industrial motors in clean, controlled environments.

Advantages: The design does not require complex enclosures or external cooling systems, reducing manufacturing and maintenance costs. No need for an external power source for cooling; the fan is driven by the rotor’s motion. Fewer additional components mean lower chances of cooling system failures.The open airflow design allows direct cooling of the end windings, where heat accumulation is common. Easy to manufacture, assemble, and repair due to fewer parts.

Drawbacks: Cooling performance is affected by the ambient conditions: High Ambient Temperatures can reduce cooling effectiveness. Dirt and debris can accumulate inside the motor, causing wear, reduced efficiency, or insulation failure. No precise regulation of the airflow or cooling effect, leading to inefficiency under variable conditions. The air gap between the rotor and stator receives minimal airflow, potentially causing localised overheating.Open machines are unsuitable for dusty, humid, or chemically active environments without additional protection.

When to Use Open Machines: Clean, Controlled Environments: Industrial settings with minimal exposure to contaminants. Applications with Moderate Cooling Needs: Machines with low to medium power ratings and duty cycles. Cost-Conscious Designs: Applications where low manufacturing and operating costs are priorities.

Self ventilated machines

In self-ventilated machines, cooling is achieved through airflow generated by a fan or impeller mounted on the rotor or shaft. This design allows the machine to cool itself during operation without requiring an external cooling mechanism.  Air is drawn into the motor by a fan attached to the rotor or shaft. The airflow passes over critical components like the stator, rotor, and end windings, removing heat and expelling it into the environment.

Common Applications include Industrial motors (e.g., Totally Enclosed Fan Cooled (TEFC) designs). Pumps, compressors, and blowers where simplicity and reliability are critical.

Advantages of Self-Ventilated Machines The machine generates its own cooling airflow, reducing dependence on additional equipment and power sources. Eliminates the need for external blowers, cooling ducts, or complex cooling systems., so simple and cost effective.The system has fewer components, leading to lower chances of failure and reduced maintenance requirements. The fan is typically integrated into the machine, saving space and simplifying installation. Suitable for moderate environments and applications with stable load conditions.

Drawbacks of Self-Ventilated Machines The cooling efficiency depends on the rotor speed; lower speeds result in reduced airflow and inadequate cooling. Dust, dirt, and moisture can impair the cooling performance and may require protective enclosures like TEFC. May not be adequate for high-power applications or extreme environments without additional cooling enhancements. The fan can generate noise, which may be undesirable in certain applications.

Design Considerations

The fan or impeller must be designed to provide sufficient airflow at the motor’s operational speed. Self-ventilated machines are often enclosed to protect internal components while allowing airflow (e.g., TEFC or Open Drip-Proof (ODP) designs). Cooling fins on the machine housing are often used to enhance heat transfer. Additional filters or protections may be required in dusty or humid environments to prevent airflow blockages or contamination.

Applications

Self-ventilated machines are suitable for:

General Industrial Use: Pumps, compressors, and conveyors in factories or processing plants.

Clean Environments: Offices, labs, or light manufacturing where environmental hazards are minimal.

Moderate Power Applications: Medium power motors where excessive heat generation is not an issue.

Axial and Radial cooling circuits

Cooling circuits in electrical machines play a crucial role in managing heat dissipation and maintaining performance. Two primary types of cooling circuits are axial cooling and radial cooling, distinguished by the direction of the cooling airflow relative to the motor’s axis.

Axial Cooling Circuit

In an axial cooling circuit, the cooling medium (typically air or liquid) flows parallel to the axis of the machine. This method is widely used in large electrical machines like generators and high-power motors.

The cooling air or liquid enters at one end of the machine and flows longitudinally along the length of the rotor or stator, Heat is extracted uniformly along the axial path.

Advantages: Suitable for machines with a long axial length, straightforward airflow management simplifies design and maintenance. Ensures consistent cooling along the machine’s length.

Disadvantages: Longer axial pathways can lead to significant pressure drop, requiring powerful fans or pumps. Limited cooling effectiveness in short or compact machines.

Applications: Large turbo-generators, high-speed motors, large alternators with axial ventilation ducts.

Radial Cooling Circuit

In a radial cooling circuit, the cooling medium flows perpendicular to the machine’s axis, typically moving outward or inward through the stator and rotor ducts.

The cooling medium flows radially outward or inward through evenly spaced ducts in the rotor and stator, often involving multiple radial flow paths for comprehensive cooling.

Advantages: Effective for machines with large diameters and heavy heat loads as they have a high cooling efficiency. Better Heat Transfer as they have direct contact with active components like stator windings and cores improves heat dissipation.

Reduced Pressure Loss due to shorter flow paths reduces the energy required for circulating the cooling medium.

Disadvantages: Requires precisely designed ducts and pathways, increasing complexity and cost. In large machines, the outer parts may cool faster than inner sections, leading to temperature gradients leading to non-uniform cooling.

Applications: Medium and large motors and generators. Electrical machines with large diameters. High-performance industrial equipment.

Comparison of Axial and Radial Cooling Circuits

Hybrid Cooling

Many modern machines combine axial and radial cooling to leverage the benefits of both systems. For instance, radial ducts may provide primary cooling, while axial fans manage airflow distribution.

By selecting the appropriate cooling circuit based on the machine’s geometry, operating conditions, and thermal management requirements, manufacturers can ensure optimal performance and longevity of electrical machines.

Liquid Cooling in Electrical Machines

Liquid cooling is a highly effective method for managing heat in electrical machines. It uses a liquid medium, such as water, oil, or specialised coolants, to absorb and dissipate heat generated by the machine’s components. This cooling method is often employed in high-power or high-performance applications where air cooling is insufficient.

Commonly used liquids include water, oil, glycol-water mixtures, and dielectric coolants.

Liquid absorbs heat from machine components and transfers it to a heat exchanger or radiator for dissipation.

Liquid Cooling Configurations

Direct Liquid Cooling: Liquid directly contacts the machine’s critical components, such as windings or rotor, providing high cooling efficiency. Requires the liquid to be non-conductive and compatible with the motor materials (e.g., dielectric coolants).

Indirect Liquid Cooling: Liquid circulates through jackets, tubes, or channels embedded in the machine housing or around specific components. Commonly used with water or glycol mixtures.

Advantages of Liquid Cooling: Liquids have higher thermal conductivity and specific heat capacity than air, allowing faster heat removal. Compact Design which enables smaller machine sizes by removing heat more efficiently. Uniform Cooling that reduces temperature gradients, minimising thermal stresses on components. Handles the heat generated by large or high-speed motors better than air cooling, so suitable for high-power applications. Eliminates or reduces the need for noisy cooling fans.

Disadvantages of Liquid Cooling: Requires additional components such as pumps, heat exchangers, and piping. More expensive to design, install, and maintain than air-cooled systems. Potential for leaks, which can damage sensitive electrical components. Requires continuous liquid circulation and a reliable heat exchanger for operation.

Components of a Liquid Cooling System

Cooling Jacket or Channel: Encases critical components like the stator or rotor, allowing heat transfer to the circulating liquid.

Pump: Drives the coolant through the system, ensuring consistent flow.

Heat Exchanger: Removes heat from the liquid, often using air or another cooling medium.

Reservoir: Stores the coolant and maintains system pressure.

Control System:Regulates temperature and flow rate for optimal performance.

Applications of Liquid Cooling: Used in motors with high power densities, such as those in electric vehicles, trains, and ships. Compressors, pumps, and turbines in demanding industrial environments. High-performance machines where compact size and reliability are critical, such as aerospace and defence. Wind turbine generators and hydroelectric generators. Liquid cooling is often used to manage heat in densely packed systems, including motor-driven server cooling systems in data centres.

Comparison of Liquid Cooling vs. Air Cooling

Oil Jet and Spray Cooling

Oil jet and spray cooling are advanced cooling techniques used in high-power or high-performance electrical machines to manage heat effectively. These methods use oil as the cooling medium, either by directing jets or sprays of oil onto critical components. The oil absorbs heat and is subsequently recirculated through a cooling system.

High-pressure oil jets or fine sprays are directed onto specific components, such as the rotor, stator windings, or bearings. The oil carries away the heat, which is then dissipated through a heat exchanger or radiator. Mineral oil, synthetic oils, or specialised dielectric oils (non-conductive) are used, depending on the application.

Oil Jet Cooling

Oil is directed at high velocity through nozzles to form jets that impinge on specific surfaces. Effective for components with high localised heat generation, such as bearings or rotor surfaces.

Applications: High-speed motors and generators where bearings experience substantial frictional heating. Industrial gearboxes in motors where both gears and bearings need efficient cooling.

Advantages: Precise cooling of specific hotspots. High heat transfer efficiency due to direct contact. Lubrication and cooling combined in one system.

Disadvantages: Requires precise nozzle alignment for effective cooling. Higher energy consumption for pumping high-pressure oil. Risk of oil contamination affecting performance

Oil Spray Cooling

Oil is atomized into fine droplets and sprayed onto the components. The spray uniformly covers surfaces, enhancing the cooling effect, especially in areas with complex geometries

Applications: Transformers and large generators with intricate winding geometries. Motors operating in high thermal stress environments, such as marine propulsion systems.

Advantages: Uniform cooling across complex surfaces. Effective for compact or densely packed components. Reduces localised overheating and temperature gradients.

Disadvantages: Requires precise control of spray patterns and flow rates. Potential for oil mist, which may require containment or ventilation. Complex system design and maintenance.

Advantages of Oil-Based Cooling Systems: Oil has a higher heat capacity than air, making it more effective for removing heat. Oil serves a dual purpose by lubricating moving parts while cooling them. Compact Design which allows for smaller motor sizes by efficiently managing thermal loads. Targets hotspots such as bearings, windings, and rotor surfaces.

Disadvantages of Oil-Based Cooling Systems: Requires pumps, nozzles, filtration, and heat exchangers. Regular oil replacement and filtration are needed to ensure performance. Oil leakage can damage surrounding equipment or pose fire hazards. Higher initial and operational costs compared to air cooling systems.

Comparison with Other Cooling Methods

How to Choose the Right Cooling Mechanism for an Electrical Machine

Selecting an appropriate cooling mechanism is crucial for the efficient and reliable operation of electrical machines. The choice depends on various factors, including the machine’s size, application, environment, and thermal load. 

Below are the general considerations to guide the selection process:

Specific Applications: High-speed motors or machines with high thermal loads often need oil jet or spray cooling. Precision applications may require liquid cooling for temperature control.

Heat Generation Thermal Load: Machines with high power density (e.g., electric vehicle motors, industrial generators) require efficient cooling systems like liquid cooling or oil jets. Localised Hotspots: Consider systems like oil spray cooling for machines prone to localised overheating.

Environmental Factors Ambient Temperature: High ambient temperatures reduce the effectiveness of air cooling; liquid cooling is preferred. Contaminants: Dust, dirt, and moisture necessitate enclosed or filtered cooling systems (e.g., TEFC motors). Hazardous Locations: Explosion-proof cooling methods may be needed in areas with flammable gases or dust.

Duty Cycle: Continuous Duty: Requires robust cooling systems like forced air or liquid cooling to handle prolonged operation. Intermittent Duty: Natural cooling or simple ventilation may suffice for shorter operating periods.

Efficiency Requirements Energy Efficiency: Air cooling is simpler and less energy-intensive but may not provide sufficient cooling for high-efficiency motors. Heat Recovery: Liquid cooling systems can integrate heat recovery for energy-saving purposes.

Maintenance and Cost Initial Cost: Air cooling is generally less expensive than liquid or oil cooling systems. Maintenance Requirements: Liquid and oil systems require regular maintenance (e.g., pump servicing, coolant replacement). Reliability: Choose simpler systems (e.g., self-ventilation) for low-maintenance needs in remote or inaccessible areas.

Space Constraints Compact Designs: Liquid cooling allows for smaller machine sizes by improving heat dissipation efficiency. Airflow Space: Air cooling requires adequate ventilation and space for fans or ducts.

Noise Levels Noise-Sensitive Environments: Liquid cooling is quieter than fan-based air cooling systems, making it suitable for offices or residential areas.

System Complexity Simple Systems: Natural cooling or self-ventilation is easy to design and maintain. Complex Systems: Advanced methods like liquid or oil cooling involve more components (e.g., pumps, heat exchangers) and higher complexity.

Cooling System Standards Ensure the cooling system complies with relevant standards (e.g., IEC 60034-6) and safety requirements for the intended application and operating environment.

---

Interested in our Electrical Engineering Courses?

At iLearn Engineering^®, we offer a diverse range of online accredited electrical engineering courses and qualifications to cater to different academic and career goals. Our courses are available in varying credit values and levels, ranging from 40 credit Engineering Diplomas to a 360 credit International Graduate Diploma.

Short Courses (40 Credits)

A selection of our more popular 40 credit electrical diplomas…

Diploma in Electrical and Electronic Engineering

Diploma in Electrical Technology

Diploma in Electronics

Diploma in Renewable Energy (Electrical)

First Year of Undergraduate (Level 4 – 120 Credits)

Higher International Certificate in Electrical and Electronic Engineering

First Two Years of Undergraduate (Level 5 – 240 Credits)

Higher International Diploma in Electrical and Electronic Engineering.

Degree equivalent Graduate Diploma (Level 6 – 360 Credits)

 International Graduate Diploma in Electrical and Electronic Engineering

All Electrical and Electronic Courses

You can read more about our selection of accredited online Electrical and Electronic Engineering courses here.

Complete Engineering Course Catalogue (all courses)

Alternatively, you can view all our online engineering courses here.